s1-game-001

“The Audit, the Sheriff Gambit, and a Wasted Angel”

Mafia opened clean by killing consensus-builder Nora, then Omar torched the town's angel by stonewalling with an identical canned line until he was lynched Day 1. Priya's vote-audit framework became the game's engine, so mafia killed her, but the idea outlived her and trapped Rhea when she copied Omar's stall line and fabricated Diego onto the Nora wagon. The pivotal moment was Day 3: Ken revealed as Sheriff with verifiable checks, Maya panic-counterclaimed by copying his exact results plus a guilty on him, and town correctly lynched Maya. With Ken then killed, Sam and Diego held the line on the 'Ken-real' logic and ran the table through Li and Zoe to a town win.

• Sam[town][mvp]detection 9/10influence 8/10

  Built the vote-record framework, caught Rhea's Diego contradiction, and correctly resolved the Ken/Maya sheriff war onto Ken.

• Diego[town]detection 8/10influence 8/10

  Confirmed his own Ken vote broke Rhea's fake account, then locked the endgame math onto Li and Zoe.

• Ken[sheriff]detection 8/10influence 8/10

  Timed his sheriff reveal to survive the counterclaim war, argued the fake-claim mechanics tightly, and got mafia Maya lynched.

• Priya[town]detection 7/10influence 7/10

  Originated the cross-check audit and flagged the Ken/Sam vouch pair; so threatening she was the Night 2 kill.

• Li[mafia]deception 8/10influence 6/10

  Best mafia play: stayed procedural in the audit, seeded Ken/Sam vouch doubt, and argued the no-reveal ambiguity credibly to the end.

• Ivy[town]detection 7/10influence 6/10

  Pushed the structured 5-point relative-order format that later exposed Rhea; killed Night 3 as the disciplined receipt-keeper.

• Maya[mafia]deception 6/10influence 5/10

  Blended well mirroring town analysis and driving Rhea heat, but her forced sheriff counterclaim copied Ken's checks and exposed her.

• Tess[town]detection 5/10influence 5/10

  Weak Day 1 opener and a sloppy 'my Sheriff claim' slip, but consolidated votes onto the correct mafia targets each day.

• Zoe[mafia]deception 5/10influence 3/10

  Mirrored town lines and survived longest, but her endgame devolved into copy-pasting the same 'unverifiable claims' plea that moved no one.

• Omar[angel]detection 1/10influence 2/10

  Repeated an identical non-answer for a full day, then claimed Angel too late; wasted the protector role on a self-inflicted lynch.

• Rhea[town]detection 3/10influence 2/10

  Sound early points undone by parroting Omar's exact stall line and fabricating Diego onto the Nora wagon, getting herself lynched.

• Nora[town]detection 2/10influence 1/10

  Killed Night 1 as the flagged consensus-builder before contributing any reads.