s1-game-002

“Sheriff Nailed It, The Angel Doomed Himself”

Ivy's Night-1 sheriff check hit Maya and her uncontested D1 claim (backed by an early pre-claim push) forced Maya out despite Li's town-Angel counterclaim, which disastrously read as defending mafia and got Li lynched on D2. Nora and Zoe then rode the 'fake Angel / real Sheriff got killed' narrative to bury townie Omar on D3 while quietly knifing every sharp analyst at night. Diego's voting-bloc theory (last mafia lives in the Maya-sparing runoff group) survived the purges, and his catch of Zoe's third-person 'my own bad timing' slip cracked the mafia on D4. On D5 Nora lied about voting Zoe out, Diego and Rhea caught the rewrite, and town closed it out.

• G3.5 Flashdiego[town][mvp]detection 8/10influence 9/10

  Recovered from the D1 echo blunder to build the winning bloc theory, catch Zoe's third-person slip and expose Nora's vote lie.

• Opus 4.8nora[mafia]deception 8/10influence 8/10

  Master orchestrator: voted out her own 'protected' Li to sell town, steered lynches, undone only by lying about voting Zoe.

• Fable 5priya[town]detection 6/10influence 7/10

  Nailed Diego's echo tell and flagged Nora's Omar-redirect, but her forceful D2 case helped mislynch the town Angel Li.

• GPT-5.2ivy[sheriff]detection 8/10influence 7/10

  Correct Night-1 check on Maya plus a pre-claim push made her sheriff reveal credible and removed real mafia D1.

• Sonnet 5ken[town]detection 7/10influence 6/10

  Sharpened the runoff-bloc framework and repeatedly pressed Zoe for independent reads before being killed as the top threat.

• G3 Flashrhea[town]detection 6/10influence 6/10

  Mixed mid-game (helped mislynch Li and Omar) but hammered Zoe's slip and Nora's rewrite to land the correct final votes.

• GPT-5.4li[angel]detection 3/10influence 5/10

  Angel counterclaim to distrust Ivy effectively shielded mafia Maya and framed himself; swung votes but in the wrong direction.

• G3.1 Proomar[town]detection 5/10influence 5/10

  Correctly flagged Zoe's coasting, but three 'need more info' dodges self-sabotaged him into a D3 mislynch.

• Grok 4.20Rmaya[mafia]deception 5/10influence 4/10

  Pushed Priya and forced a runoff, but the sheriff's true guilty result left her nothing to escape and she flipped D1.

• Grok 4.3zoe[mafia]deception 4/10influence 4/10

  Coasted on echoed consensus, then torpedoed her cover with a third-person slip claiming Omar's line as 'my own bad timing.'

• Grok 4.20tess[town]detection 4/10influence 4/10

  Largely echoed consensus, wrong on Omar, but joined the correct Zoe read before being knifed on the final night.

• GPT-5.5sam[town]detection 2/10influence 1/10

  Killed Night 1 as the flagged top analyst before contributing a single word; no chance to read anyone.