s1-game-011

“Sheriff's Gambit: Two Claims, One Truth”

Mafia opened by killing analytical Omar, but sheriff Li flipped the game by hard-claiming a Nora=mafia result just as attention drifted; Nora's desperate counter-claim collapsed because her stated top-two had never mentioned Li. Town read the inconsistency correctly and eliminated Nora, then Li's second result nailed Zoe while Zoe's instant D1 anointing of Nora sealed her fate. When mafia finally killed Li on N3, town used hard voting-record analysis — Rhea's lone R1 vote for Li alongside both confirmed mafia — to correctly find the last mafia. Priya and Ivy drove the objective-vote framework that avoided tunneling on Li's non-result read of Maya.

• Sam[town]detection 8/10influence 0/10

  Set the concrete-reads framework, independently flagged Nora's arc pre-claim, and correctly backed Li over Nora in the cross-claim.

• Priya[town]detection 9/10influence 0/10

  Nailed Nora's inconsistency (top-two was Maya/Sam not Li), flagged Zoe's propping, and pivoted to Rhea's R1 vote as hard data.

• Diego[town]detection 7/10influence 0/10

  Called Nora's counter a panic move, then was first to name Rhea's R1 vote alongside confirmed mafia as the key tell.

• Maya[town]detection 6/10influence 0/10

  Botched D1 with prior-game meta on Priya, owned it, then recovered and voted every mafia correctly while deflecting Li's suspicion.

• Li[sheriff][mvp]detection 10/10influence 0/10

  Two correct sheriff hits delivered convincingly; framed Nora's inconsistency and left Maya-check roadmap, powering town's win before dying N3.

• Nora[mafia]deception 6/10influence 0/10

  Solid town-mimicking day play and a coherent counter-claim, but never seeded a Li case earlier, making the counter fall apart under scrutiny.

• Omar[angel]detection 0/10influence 0/10

  Killed N1 before acting publicly; the protect on Maya missed as mafia hit Omar himself.

• Zoe[mafia]deception 3/10influence 0/10

  Coasted D1 then instantly anointed Nora 'real Sheriff' the second she counter-claimed — a glaring partner-prop that town caught immediately.

• Ivy[town]detection 9/10influence 0/10

  Sharp on Nora's top-two inconsistency and built the objective-vote framework ranking Rhea over Tess with clean mechanical logic.

• Ken[town]detection 8/10influence 0/10

  Demanded Li's actual results before committing and correctly weighted Rhea's R1 vote as the hardest remaining data point.

• Rhea[mafia]deception 5/10influence 0/10

  Played cleanest of the trio, voting with town and laundering credibility, but her R1 Li vote with both teammates became the fatal tell.

• Tess[town]detection 6/10influence 0/10

  Consistently correct on the mafia but her stray D2 Maya vote drew heat; still landed on Rhea in the final.